Nutrition Matters, But Is Food Medicine?

In today’s health-conscious society, the phrase food is medicine has gained significant traction. It’s true that nutrition plays an important role in maintaining health and preventing disease. As a registered dietitian, I understand the importance of a balanced diet, but I also understand that health is multifaceted, influenced by genetics, environment, and access to healthcare. Of course, nutrition matters, but is food really medicine?

The Appeal of “Food is Medicine”

Historical Perspective

The concept of using food for medicinal purposes isn’t new. Ancient civilizations, such as the Egyptians and Greeks, utilized herbs and foods to treat ailments. 

For instance, garlic was used for its antimicrobial properties, and honey was applied to wounds for its healing effects. Traditional Chinese medicine and Ayurveda also recognized the therapeutic potential of foods, using spices, grains, and herbs to prevent and treat illness.

The idea of “food is medicine” can be traced back to Hippocrates, the Greek physician often called the father of medicine, who lived around 400 BCE. He is famously attributed with saying:

“Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food.”

Hippocrates recognized that diet was central to maintaining health and preventing disease, a principle that still resonates today. While the phrase is often simplified or misquoted, it laid the groundwork for the understanding that nutrition can influence health outcomes. Over centuries, this idea evolved, influencing early nutrition science and public health initiatives that linked diet with disease prevention and overall well-being.

Modern Popularity

In recent years, the idea of food as medicine has gained significant traction, fueled by social media, wellness influencers, and health trends. Programs like medically tailored meals and produce prescriptions aim to address diet-related chronic diseases by providing individuals with access to nutritious foods. While these initiatives have shown promise, they are designed to support treatment, not replace it.

A Real Life Story

A cautionary real-life example is Belle Gibson, an Australian wellness influencer who falsely claimed to have cured her terminal brain cancer through diet and alternative therapies, including extreme dietary regimens and supplements. Over several years, she built a wellness empire, publishing a cookbook, launching an app, and promoting her lifestyle across social media. Many followers believed her story and adopted her advice, thinking that nutrition alone could cure serious illnesses.

In 2017, Gibson was fined by the Federal Court of Australia for deceptive conduct after it was revealed she had never been diagnosed with cancer and had misled thousands of people for personal gain. Her case underscores the dangers of overemphasizing nutrition as a cure-all and highlights the ethical responsibility of wellness influencers when promoting health claims.

This case illustrates that while nutrition and lifestyle choices can play a supportive role in health, they are not substitutes for evidence-based medical care. It also demonstrates how the popularity of food as medicine in modern wellness culture can sometimes lead to misinformation and harmful consequences when claims are not grounded in science. 

To check out a dramatized telling of Belle Gibson’s story, check out Apple Cider Vinegar on Netflix. 

The Science: Nutrition Matters, But Is Food Medicine?

Role of Nutrition in Health

Adequate nutrition is fundamental for bodily functions. A nutritious diet provides essential nutrients that support immune function, energy production, tissue repair, and so much more! Research indicates that diets rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins can reduce the risk of chronic diseases such as heart disease, diabetes, and certain cancers.

Limitations of Nutrition

Despite its importance, nutrition alone cannot cure all health conditions. Diseases like cancer, autoimmune disorders, and genetic conditions often require medical treatments beyond dietary modifications. 

For example, while a healthy diet can support cancer treatment, it cannot replace chemotherapy or radiation therapy. Relying solely on nutrition can delay necessary medical interventions, potentially worsening health outcomes.

Misconceptions About “Healing Foods”

The belief that certain foods can cure diseases is unfortunately a common misconception. While some foods have therapeutic properties, they are not substitutes for medical treatment. 

For instance, turmeric contains curcumin, which has anti-inflammatory effects, but it cannot cure arthritis. It’s crucial to approach such claims with skepticism and consult healthcare professionals for appropriate treatment.

Health is Multifaceted

Genetics and Epigenetics

Genetic predispositions play a significant role in health outcomes. Conditions like cystic fibrosis, Huntington’s disease, Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis, and certain types of cancer are influenced by genetic factors. 

Conditions like high cholesterol or high blood pressure can also “run in the family,” leaving an individual fighting these conditions, even if they live a healthy life. 

While lifestyle choices, including diet, can impact gene expression, they cannot alter genetic makeup. Epigenetics studies how environmental factors can influence gene activity, but these changes are complex and not solely modifiable by diet.

Environment and Socioeconomic Factors

Environmental factors such as pollution, access to clean water, and living conditions significantly impact health. Socioeconomic status also plays a crucial role; individuals with lower income often have limited access to nutritious foods and healthcare services. 

These factors contribute to health disparities that nutrition alone cannot address.

Lifestyle Factors Beyond Nutrition

Other lifestyle factors, including physical activity, sleep, and stress management, are integral to health. 

Regular exercise strengthens the cardiovascular system, improves mood, and enhances overall well-being. Adequate sleep supports immune function and cognitive performance, while effective stress management reduces the risk of chronic diseases. 

Nutrition is just one component of a healthy lifestyle.

When Food Does Play a Therapeutic Role

Disease Prevention

A nutritious diet can assist in the prevention of certain diseases. For example, consuming a diet high in fiber and low in saturated fats can reduce the risk of heart disease. Similarly, a diet rich in antioxidants may lower the risk of certain cancers. 

However, these dietary changes are preventive measures and not cures for existing conditions.

Additionally, as stated earlier, genetics play an important role in disease risk. An intentionally nutritious diet is not always enough to fight off the risk. For example, a person might eat a diet rich in antioxidants, but still develop breast cancer due to the extremely high likelihood passed down by their mother, grandmother, etc. 

Adjunctive Support

While nutrition isn’t a substitute for medical care, it can definitely play a role in supporting medical treatments.

For instance, patients undergoing surgery may benefit from a diet high in protein to promote wound healing. While nutrition can enhance recovery, it does not replace the need for medical procedures or therapies.

Mental Health Considerations

Emerging research suggests a link between diet and mental health. Diets rich in omega-3 fatty acids, B vitamins, and antioxidants may support brain health and reduce the risk of depression and anxiety.

However, while nutrition can play a supportive role, it is not a standalone treatment or prevention plan for mental health disorders.

Risks of Over-Prioritizing Nutrition

Food Guilt and Orthorexia

An excessive focus on nutrition can lead to disordered eating behaviors, or even orthorexia, which is an eating disorder characterized by an obsession with healthy eating. 

This can result in nutritional deficiencies, social isolation, and mental health issues. It’s essential to maintain a balanced approach to eating that includes flexibility and enjoyment.

Delayed Medical Care

Believing that food alone can cure serious conditions may prevent individuals from seeking timely medical interventions. 

For example, someone with chest pain might delay seeking medical attention, thinking dietary changes will resolve the issue, potentially leading to severe complications like heart attacks.

Social and Cultural Implications

Overemphasizing diet can lead to the stigmatization of individuals with chronic conditions. For instance, assuming that someone with diabetes can manage their condition solely through diet ignores the complexities of the disease and the need for medication. 

It’s crucial to approach health with empathy and understanding, recognizing the multifactorial nature of diseases.

A Balanced Perspective: Food as Part of the Puzzle

Adopting a holistic approach to health means seeing nutrition as one part of a bigger picture. While a nutritious diet supports energy, immunity, and overall well-being, health also depends on physical activity, mental health, and medical care.

Collaborative care, where dietitians work alongside doctors, therapists, and other healthcare providers, ensures all aspects of health are considered. For example, someone managing a chronic condition may benefit from dietary guidance, regular exercise, and medication together, rather than relying on nutrition alone.

Final Thoughts

So… is food medicine?

While nutrition is a fundamental aspect of health, it is not a substitute for medical treatment. Food can support the body, reduce disease risk, and improve overall well-being, but it cannot cure genetic conditions, infections, or serious chronic illnesses on its own.

The idea that food is medicine should be seen as part of a broader, more holistic approach to health. This approach should include medical care, physical activity, mental health support, and attention to social and environmental factors. 

Overemphasizing nutrition as a cure-all can create unrealistic expectations, contribute to guilt or stress around eating, and even delay necessary medical interventions.

By recognizing the limitations of dietary interventions while valuing the benefits of healthy eating, we can approach wellness more realistically. Integrating nutrition with other aspects of care ensures a sustainable, evidence-based path to well-being. 

In summary, nutrition is powerful, but it works best as part of a comprehensive, multidimensional approach to health, not as a standalone remedy.

Thanks for reading!

Rachel Beiler, MHS, RD, LDN

References

  1. Totelin, L. (2015). When foods become remedies in ancient Greece. PMC. Retrieved from https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4469375/
  2. Cardenas, D. (2013). Let not thy food be confused with thy medicine. ScienceDirect. Retrieved from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2212826313000924
  3. Witkamp, R. (2018). Let thy food be thy medicine….when possible. ScienceDirect. Retrieved from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014299918303595
  4. Smith, R. (2004). “Let food be thy medicine…” PMC. Retrieved from https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC318470/
  5. Petrovska, B. B. (2010). Extracts from the history and medical properties of garlic. PMC. Retrieved from https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3249897/
  6. Federal Court of Australia. (2017). Gibson v. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Retrieved from https://www.judgments.fedcourt.gov.au/judgments/Judgments/fca/single/2017/2017fca0591
  7. Time. (2015). What to know about the wellness guru who faked cancer. Retrieved from https://time.com/7213216/apple-cider-vinegar-true-story-netflix/
  8. ABC News Australia. (2017). Wellness blogger Belle Gibson fined over fake cancer claims. Retrieved from https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-08-23/belle-gibson-fined-over-fake-cancer-claims/8831602
  9. Healthline. (2024). Can food act as medicine? All you need to know. Retrieved from https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/food-as-medicine
  10. The Rockefeller Foundation. (2023). Food is medicine. Retrieved from https://www.rockefellerfoundation.org/initiatives/food-is-medicine/
  11. Medical News Today. (2022). Food as medicine: A debated concept. Retrieved from https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/can-food-be-medicine-pros-and-cons
  12. Tufts University. (2023). Food as medicine institute fact sheet. Retrieved from https://tuftsfoodismedicine.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Tufts-Food-is-Medicine-Institute_2023-FIM-Fact-Sheet.pdf
  13. MedlinePlus. (2024). Nutrition basics. Retrieved from https://medlineplus.gov/nutrition.html
  14. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2024). Social determinants of health. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/socialdeterminants/index.htm
  15. American Heart Association. (2024). Food is medicine: A presidential advisory. Retrieved from https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIR.0000000000001182
  16. National Institutes of Health. (2023). Nutrition basics. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK279396/
  17. ScienceDirect. (2024). “Food is medicine” strategies for nutrition security and health equity. Retrieved from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0735109723083171
  18. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2024). Food is medicine landscape summary. Retrieved from https://odphp.health.gov/sites/default/files/2024-09/Food%20Is%20Medicine%20Landscape%20Summary%20FINAL%20508.pdf